Mozilla v. FCC is a win for innovation, but legislation is still needed

Today’s 2-1 ruling in Mozilla v. Federal Communications Commission from the D.C. Circuit largely reaffirms the FCC’s 2018 net neutrality framework, avoiding an innovation-crushing regulatory regime. However, as Lincoln Network co-founder Garrett Johnson argued, Congress still needs to step in to address the harmful regulatory uncertainty of the protracted fight over net neutrality: 

While some organizations purporting to represent Silicon Valley startups pushed for 1930’s utility-style regulation of the internet, Lincoln Network and a coalition of startups and innovators have consistently advocated for a bipartisan legislative solution guaranteeing an open internet for consumers. Today’s D.C. Circuit Court decision preserves the critical freedoms enacted in 2018, but Congress must still act to provide regulatory certainty over the long term.

This debate hasn’t just been limited to the federal government. Several dozen states have entered the fray with their own net neutrality legislation. A controversial, and misunderstood, part of the D.C. Circuit’s decision was qualifying the FCC’s ability to preempt state net neutrality laws. While state laws aren’t preempted by default, they are still vulnerable to preemption on a case-by-case basis. Nonetheless, this still creates a murky regulatory landscape in the near term.

When the FCC issued the Restoring Internet Freedom Order, opponents spun a vision of a dystopian internet that was dominated by anti-competitive behavior. Their solution was to call for the internet to be regulated akin to a public utility and limit what kinds of economic activity could exist. Now, nearly two years later, it is clear that the fearful warnings of an internet dark age were overwrought political posturing. It’s now time for Congress to settle the debate once and for all.

Tags: ,

Image
Name
Designation
Short Description
Social Links
Dan Lips
Director of Cyber and National Security
Grace Meyer
Development Manager
William Upton
Director of Communications and Outreach
Garret Johnson Lincoln Executive Director
Garrett Johnson
Co-Founder and Executive Director
Zach Graves
Head of Policy
Aaron Ginn
Co-Founder
Subscribe to our newsletterStay up to date with our latest posts and events

Join the largest community of tech professionals devoted to building alliance of liberty and technology. Lincoln is a place to learn, connect, and influence the future of our society.

Sign up and you'll get:

  • A weekly Lincoln Letters newsletter with the latest need-to-know on news, tech and politics
  • Exclusive invitations to events where you’ll meet like-minded folks and grow your network